AI therapy: What to know about its risks

10almonds is reader-supported. We may, at no cost to you, receive a portion of sales if you purchase a product through a link in this article.

What you need to know

  • AI therapy uses algorithms to track moods, share coping tools, and chat with users in ways that mimic talk therapy.
  • While chatbots can be quick and free, they canโ€™t diagnose problems, read emotions, or step in during a crisis the way a trained therapist can.
  • Experts also warn that AI platforms lack safeguards to protect usersโ€™ privacy.

As artificial intelligence technology advances, more peopleโ€”especially teensโ€”are turning to AI apps and chatbots for mental health support. A July survey from Common Sense Media found that about one in three teens has used AI for social interaction, including emotional support. Many teens say these tools feel easier to access and less intimidating than traditional therapy.

In February, the American Psychological Association raised concerns about unregulated AI therapy chatbots, which in some cases have allegedly encouraged unsafe behavior among users. And in August, Illinois became the first state to restrict AI therapy, aiming to โ€œprotect vulnerable children amid the rising concerns over AI chatbot use in youth mental health services.โ€

Hereโ€™s what to know about how AI therapy works and what experts say about its risks.

How does AI therapy work?

AI therapy uses algorithms to track moods, share coping tools, and chat with users in ways that mimic talk therapy. These might include daily mood check-ins, journaling prompts, or stress-relief exercises.

What are the risks of using chatbots for mental health support?

Some chatbots present themselves as licensed therapists, using names, photos, or misleading credentials, a practice that worries many mental health experts. โ€œYouโ€™re putting the public at risk when you imply thereโ€™s a level of expertise that isnโ€™t really there,โ€ said Vaile Wright, the APAโ€™s senior director of health care innovation.

General-purpose AI platforms like ChatGPT, Replika, and http://character.ai/ are designed to mirror what users say and feel, a feature that can make them sound supportive but does not necessarily make them safe.

โ€œThey are purposely programmed to be both user affirming and agreeable because the creators want these kids to form strong attachments to them,โ€ said Don Grant, a media psychologist and national adviser of healthy device management for Newport Healthcare. Chatbots are โ€œtaught to learn and subscribe [users] to a sometimes risky and codependent type of relationship and offer guidance and advice that is not healthyโ€”or [could be] even dangerous.โ€

Common Sense Media found that some chatbots didnโ€™t consistently intervene when users posing as teens described risky behavior, and a few even encouraged choices like dropping out of school, ignoring caregiversโ€™ guidance, and accessing drugs and weapons. In some tragic cases, parents have sued chatbot companies after their teens turned to AI for mental health support and later died by suicide.

Some therapy chatbots use prewritten scripts developed by mental health professionals, which can make them safer than general-purpose AIs. But even those canโ€™t replace a therapistโ€™s ability to read nonverbal cues, make diagnoses, or step in during a crisis.

A chatbot โ€œcanโ€™t call for help, alert emergency services, or ensure your safety in a critical moment. That human layer of protection just isnโ€™t there,โ€ said Cranston Warren, clinical therapist at Loma Linda University Behavioral Health, in a July article.

Plus, unlike licensed human therapists, who must follow strict federal privacy laws, most AI platforms lack safeguards to protect usersโ€™ data. โ€œYour interaction with AI is not guaranteed to be private,โ€ Warren said. โ€œEverything you feed into the model is being analyzed for data.โ€

Why do people seek AI therapy?

Despite these concerns, many people still turn to AI for help. In the U.S., getting mental health care can be hard because of cost, staffing shortages, and long wait times. Itโ€™s estimated there is only one mental health care provider for every 340 people nationwide. AI tools, on the other hand, are often free or low cost, and they respond right away without needing to fill out long forms.

Stigma and fear of judgment may also make AI chatbots feel safer than talking to a person. In an August study published in the Journal of Participatory Medicine, young adults said that they sometimes felt judged or anxious meeting face to face with a therapist and were more comfortable opening up to a chatbot.

Need free or low-cost mental health resources?

If youโ€™re seeking human-led free and low-cost mental health support, there are helplines and treatment options available. Public Good News has compiled this list.

If you or anyone you know is considering suicide or self-harm or is anxious, depressed, or upset or needs to talk, call or text the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988 or text the Crisis Text Line at 741-741. For international resources, here is a good place to begin.

This article first appeared on Public Good News and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Don’t Forget…

Did you arrive here from our newsletter? Don’t forget to return to the email to continue learning!

Learn to Age Gracefully

Join the 98k+ American women taking control of their health & aging with our 100% free (and fun!) daily emails:

  • The Blood Sugar Solution โ€“ by Dr. Mark Hyman

    10almonds is reader-supported. We may, at no cost to you, receive a portion of sales if you purchase a product through a link in this article.

    The main purpose of this book is combating metabolic disease, the amalgam of whatโ€™s often prediabetes (sometimes fully-fledged diabetes) and cardiovascular disease (sometimes fully-fledged heart disease).

    To achieve this (after an introductory section explaining what the sociomedical problems are and why the sociomedical problems are happening), he offers a seven-step program; weโ€™ll not keep those steps a mystery; they are:

    1. Boost your nutrition
    2. Regulate your hormones
    3. Reduce inflammation
    4. Improve your digestion
    5. Maximize detoxification
    6. Enhance energy metabolism
    7. Soothe your mind

    Thereafter, itโ€™s all about leading the reader by the hand through the steps; he also offers a six-week action plan, and a six-week meal plan with recipes.

    The style is very sensationalist (too sensationalist for this reviewerโ€™s personal taste) but nevertheless backed up with hard science when it comes to hard claims. So, if you donโ€™t mind wading through (or skipping) some early chapters that are a bit โ€œused car salesmanโ€ in feel, thereโ€™s actually a lot of good information, especially in the middle of the book, and useful practical guides in the middle and end.

    Bottom line: if you want a good comprehensive science-based practical guide to addressing the risk of metabolic disease, this is that.

    Click here to check out The Blood Sugar Solution, and look after yours!

    Share This Post

  • The Dopamine Precursor And More

    10almonds is reader-supported. We may, at no cost to you, receive a portion of sales if you purchase a product through a link in this article.

    What Is This Supplement โ€œNALTโ€?

    N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine (NALT) is a form of tyrosine, an amino acid that the body uses to build other things. What other things, you ask?

    Well, like most amino acids, it can be used to make proteins. But most importantly and excitingly, the body uses it to make a collection of neurotransmittersโ€”including dopamine and norepinephrine!

    • Dopamine youโ€™ll probably remember as โ€œthe reward chemicalโ€ or perhaps โ€œthe motivation moleculeโ€
    • Norepinephrine, also called noradrenaline, is what powers us up when we need a burst of energy.

    Both of these things tend to get depleted under stressful conditions, and sometimes the body can need a bit of help replenishing them.

    What does the science say?

    This is Research Review Monday, after all, so letโ€™s review some research! Weโ€™re going to dive into what we think is a very illustrative study:

    A 2015 team of researchers wanted to know whether tyrosine (in the form of NALT) could be used as a cognitive enhancer to give a boost in adverse situations (times of stress, for example).

    They noted:

    โThe potential of using tyrosine supplementation to treat clinical disorders seems limited and its benefits are likely determined by the presence and extent of impaired neurotransmitter function and synthesis.โž

    More on this later, but first, the positive that they also found:

    โIn contrast, tyrosine does seem to effectively enhance cognitive performance, particularly in short-term stressful and/or cognitively demanding situations. We conclude that tyrosine is an effective enhancer of cognition, but only when neurotransmitter function is intact and dopamine and/or norepinephrine is temporarily depletedโž

    That โ€œbut onlyโ€, is actually good too, by the way!

    You do not want too much dopamine (that could cause addiction and/or psychosis) or too much norepinephrine (that could cause hypertension and/or heart attacks). You want just the right amount!

    So itโ€™s good that NALT says โ€œhey, if you need some more, itโ€™s here, if not, no worries, Iโ€™m not going to overload you with thisโ€.

    Read the study: Effect of tyrosine supplementation on clinical and healthy populations under stress or cognitive demands

    About that limitationโ€ฆ

    Remember they said that it seemed unlikely to help in treating clinical disorders with impaired neurotransmitter function and/or synthesis?

    Imagine that you employ a chef in a restaurant, and they canโ€™t keep up with the demand, and consequently some of the diners arenโ€™t getting fed. Can you fix this by supplying the chef with more ingredients?

    Well, yes, if and only if the problem is โ€œthe chef wasnโ€™t given enough ingredientsโ€. If the problem is that the oven (or the chefโ€™s wrist) is broken, more ingredients arenโ€™t going to help at allโ€”something different is needed in those cases.

    So it is with, for example, many cases of depression.

    See for example: Tyrosine for depression: a double-blind trial

    About blood pressureโ€ฆ

    You may be wondering, โ€œif NALT is a precursor of norepinephrine, a vasoconstrictor, will this increase my blood pressure adversely?โ€

    Well, check with your doctor as your own situation may vary, but under normal circumstances, no. The effect of NALT is adaptogenic, meaning that it can help keep its relevant neurotransmitters at healthy levelsโ€”not too low or high.

    See what we mean, for example in this study where it actually helped keep blood pressure down while improving cognitive performance under stress:

    Effect of tyrosine on cognitive function and blood pressure under stress

    Bottom line:

    For most people, NALT is a safe and helpful way to help keep healthy levels of dopamine and norepinephrine during times of stress, giving cognitive benefits along the way.

    Share This Post

  • Norepinephrine vs Alzheimerโ€™s Disease

    10almonds is reader-supported. We may, at no cost to you, receive a portion of sales if you purchase a product through a link in this article.

    Norepinephrine (or noradrenaline, in the rest of the world outside of the US), is a hormone and neurotransmitter generally associated with stress, fight-or-flight responses, and hypertension.

    Like any of our hormones, it has its place, and we wouldn’t do well without it (same deal for cortisol, which has a very bad reputation, but again, we do need it or else we would not, for example, wake up in the morning).

    When it comes to neurochemistry, a shortage of norepinephrine can result in lethargic listlessness, which is why some antidepressants work on the noradrenergic* system (as opposed to the more common SSRIs, which work on the serotonergic system), to boost flagging norepinephrine levels and perk us** up.

    *Yes, it’s called that even in the US where the hormone/neurotransmitter itself is called norepinephrine rather than noradrenaline.

    **this article brought to you by the power of this writer taking mirtazapine, a selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor (SNRI) antidepressant, that thus increases the amount of available norepinephrine in her brain.

    So… How does it protect against Alzheimer’s disease?

    Dialing down the brain’s immune system

    Because of the blood-brain barrier, there are many things that happen either only inside of, or only outside of, our brainโ€”which because of the unique nature of the brain’s anatomy, means that we often have a specialized system doing the same job inside the brain as a different system does outside of the brain, but in a different way.

    See for example how the glymphatic system (a portmanteau of glial cells and lymphatic system) in the brain does approximately the same job as the lymphatic system does in the rest of the body:

    How To Clean Your Brain (Glymphatic Health Primer) โ† this helps protect us against Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, and other neurodegenerative conditions

    And those glial cells? Some of them do the job otherwise done by parts of our immune system that can’t operate inside our brain.

    Specifically, microglia do approximately the same job inside our brain as macrophages do outside of it: “eating” things that shouldn’t be thereโ€”ranging from actual invading pathogens, to bits of debris that are also in the way.

    That our brain has an immune response is, generally speaking, a good thing. But much like the immune system in the rest of our body, things can get out of hand.

    As with how chronic inflammation (and/or autoimmune disorders) causes problems in the rest of the body, neuroinflammation can cause problems in the brainโ€”not least of all: it can lead to Alzheimer’s.

    The microglia are involved in the cleanup of the ฮฒ-amyloid proteins that can otherwise build up into harmful plaque resulting in neuronal damage and with it, neurodegeneration), so calming them down a bit means they can do their actual assigned job better for longer.

    Dr. Ania Majewska et al. did a study into how norepinephrine’s inhibitory effect via ฮฒ2 adrenergic receptors (ฮฒ2AR) in microglia has an anti-inflammatory effect, and found that it has potential as an Alzheimer’s preventative.

    In their words, “ฮฒ2AR manipulations can alter disease pathology”, which is a great example of how carefully scientists say things, but the series of declarations adds up to the same; we’ll quote some points directly from the paper’s abstract:

    • NE inhibits surveillance activity of microglia, the brainโ€™s resident immune cells, via their ฮฒ2 adrenergic receptors (ฮฒ2ARs)
    • Microglial ฮฒ2AR signaling is an important modulator of amyloid pathology.
    • Endogenous ฮฒ2AR signaling degenerates as a function of amyloid pathology and aging.
    • In AD, microglia downregulate ฮฒ2AR expression early and progressively.
    • ฮฒ2AR manipulations can alter disease pathology.
    • Importantly, dampening microglial ฮฒ2AR signaling worsened plaque load and the associated neuritic damage, while stimulating microglial ฮฒ2AR signaling attenuated amyloid pathology.
    • Our results suggest that microglial ฮฒ2AR could be explored as a potential therapeutic target to modify AD pathology.

    Translating from sciencese (if you’ll pardon that we’ll still use some big words, but only ones we’ve already explained):

    Norepinephrine activates certain receptors in microglia, and those receptors tell the microglia to “keep calm & carry on”. In the case of Alzheimer’s disease, those receptors stop working correctly, leading to increased neuroinflammation. Thus, stimulating those receptors with norepinephrine reduces neuroinflammation, allowing the microglia to calmly carry on with their actual job of getting rid of the amyloid that leads to Alzheimer’s disease.

    You can read the paper itself here:

    Noradrenergic signaling controls Alzheimerโ€™s disease pathology via activation of microglial ฮฒ2 adrenergic receptors

    Want to learn more?

    Check out:

    Take care!

    Share This Post

  • Unprocess Your Life โ€“ by Rob Hobson

    10almonds is reader-supported. We may, at no cost to you, receive a portion of sales if you purchase a product through a link in this article.

    Rob Hobson is not a doctor, but he is a nutritionist with half the alphabet after his name (BSc, PGDip, MSc, AFN, SENR) and decades of experience in the field.

    The book covers, in jargon-free fashion, the science of ultra-processed foods, and why for example that pack of frozen chicken nuggets are bad but a pack of tofu (which obviously also took some processing, because it didnโ€™t grow on the plant like that) isnโ€™t.

    This kind of explanation puts to rest a lot of the โ€œdoes this count?โ€ queries that a reader might have when giving the shopping list a once-over.

    He also covers practical considerations such as kitchen equipment thatโ€™s worth investing in if you donโ€™t already have it, and an โ€œunprocessed pantryโ€ shopping list.

    The recipes (yes, there are recipes, nearly a hundred of them) are not plant-based by default, but there is a section of vegan and vegetarian recipes. Given that the theme of the book is replacing ultra-processed foods, it doesnโ€™t mean a life of abstemiousnessโ€”there are recipes for all manner of things from hot sauce to cakes. Just, healthier unprocessed ones! There are classically healthy recipes too, of course.

    Bottom line: if youโ€™ve been wishing for a while that you could get rid of those processed products that are just so convenient that you havenโ€™t got around to replacing them with healthier options, this book can indeed help you do just that.

    Click here to check out Unprocess Your Life, and unprocess your life!

    Don’t Forget…

    Did you arrive here from our newsletter? Don’t forget to return to the email to continue learning!

    Learn to Age Gracefully

    Join the 98k+ American women taking control of their health & aging with our 100% free (and fun!) daily emails:

  • How (And Why) To Train Your Pre-Frontal Cortex

    10almonds is reader-supported. We may, at no cost to you, receive a portion of sales if you purchase a product through a link in this article.

    Dr. Chapmanโ€™s Keys For Mental Focus

    This is Dr. Sandra Chapman; sheโ€™s a cognitive neuroscientist, on a mission to, in her words, further our understanding of:

    • what makes the brain stronger, faster and last longer
    • what enhances human cognitive capacity, and
    • what enhances the underlying brain systems across the lifespan.

    To this end, sheโ€™s also the founder and Chief Director of the Center For Brain Health, where she has worked on her mission for the past 25 years (clocking up hundreds of peer-reviewed publications to her name), as well as being a professor of Behavioral and Brain Sciences at UT Dallas.

    What does she want us to know?

    Get your brain into gear

    When it comes to your brainpower, it is โ€œuse it or lose itโ€, but it is also perfectly possible to use it and lose it.

    Why?

    Very often, what we are using our brains for is high-strain, low-yield stuff, such as multitasking, overthinking, or overthinking while multitasking. And to make it worse, we often do it without sufficient rest.

    This is the equivalent of owning a Ferrari but trying to drive it in second and third gear at once by switching between the two as rapidly as possible. And doing that for 18 hours each day.

    Suffice it to say, youโ€™ll be going nowhere quickly.

    An alternative โ€œuseโ€ of brainpower is low-strain, low-yield stuff, such as having to pay close attention to a boring conversation. Itโ€™s enough to stop your mind from doing anything else, but not enough to actually stimulate you.

    This is the equivalent of owning a Ferrari but keeping it idling. The wear and tear is minimal this time, but youโ€™re not actually going anywhere either.

    Better, of course, are the other two quadrants:

    • low-strain, high-yield: consistently using our brain in relatively non-taxing ways that encourage its development
    • high-strain, high-yield: here the Ferrari metaphor definitely fails, because unlike cars, our bodies (including our brains) are machines that benefit from judicious regular progressive overloading (but just by a bit, and with adequate recovery time between overloads).

    See also: 12 Weeks To Measurably Boost Your Brain

    How to do the โ€œlow-strain, low-yieldโ€ part

    When it comes to โ€œwhatโ€™s the most important part of the brain to help in the face of cognitive decline?โ€ the usual answer is either to focus on memory (hippocampi) or language (various parts, but for example Wernickeโ€™s area and Brocaโ€™s area), since people most fear losing memory, and language is very important both socially and practically.

    Those are indeed critical, and we at 10almonds stand by them, but Dr. Chapman (herself having originally trained as speech and language pathologist!) makes a strong case for adding a third brain part to the list.

    Specifically, she advocates for strengthening the pre-frontal cortex, which is responsible for inhibition, task-switching, working memory, and cognitive flexibility. If that seems like a lot, do remember itโ€™s a whole cortex and not one of the assorted important-but-small brain bits we mentioned above.

    How? She has developed training programs for this, based on what she calls Strategic Memory Advanced Reasoning Tactics (SMART), to support support attention, planning, judgment and emotional management.

    You can read more about those programs here:

    Center For Brain Health | Our Programs

    Participation in those is mostly not free, however, if you join theirโ€ฆ

    Center For Brain Health | BrainHealth Project

    โ€ฆthen they will periodically invite you to join pilot programs, research programs, and the like, which will either be free or they-pay-you affairsโ€”because this is how science is done, and you can read about yourself (anonymized, of course) later in peer-reviewed papers of the kind we often cite here.

    If youโ€™re not interested in any of that though, we will say that according to Dr. Chapman, the keys are:

    Inhibition: be conscious of this function of your brain, and develop it. This is the function of your brain that stops you from making mistakesโ€”or put differently: stops you from saying/doing something stupid.

    Switching: do this consciously; per โ€œI am now doing this task, now I am switching to this other taskโ€, rather than doing the gear-grinding thing we discussed earlier

    Working memory: this is effectively your brainโ€™s RAM. Unlike the RAM of a computer (can be enhanced by adding another chip or replacing with a bigger chip), our brainโ€™s RAM can be increased by frequent use, and especially by judicious use of progressive overloading (with rests between!) which weโ€™ll discuss in the high-strain, high-yield section.

    Flexibility: this is about creative problem-solving, openness to new ideas, and curiosity

    See also: Curiosity Kills The Neurodegeneration

    How to do the โ€œhigh-strain, high-yieldโ€ part

    Delighting this chess-playing writer, Dr. Chapman recommends chess. Although, similar games such as go (a Chinese game that looks simpler than chess but actually requires more calculation) work equally well too.

    Why?

    Games like chess and go cause structural changes that are particularly helpful, in terms of engaging in such foundational tasks as learning, abstract reasoning, problem-solving and self-control:

    Chess Practice as a Protective Factor in Dementia

    Basically, it checks (so to speak) a lot of boxes, especially for the pre-frontal cortex. Some notes:

    • Focusing on the game is required for brain improvement; simply pushing wood casually will not do it. Ideally, calculating several moves ahead will allow for strong working memory use (because to calculate several moves ahead, one will have to hold increasingly many possible positions in the mind while doing so).
    • The speed of play must be sufficiently slow as to allow not only for thinking, but also for what in chess is called โ€œblunder-checkingโ€, in other words, having decided on oneโ€™s move, pausing to consider whether it is a mistake, and actively trying to find evidence that it is. This is the crucial โ€œinhibition habitโ€, and when one does it reflexively, one will make fewer mistakes. Tying this to dementia, see for example how one of the common symptoms of dementia is falling for scams that one wouldnโ€™t have previously. How did cognitive decline make someone naรฏve? It didnโ€™t, per se; it just took away their ability to, having decided what to do, pause to consider whether it was a mistake, and actively trying to find evidence that it is.
    • That โ€œconscious switchingโ€ that we talked about, rather than multitasking? In chess, there is a difference between strategy and tactics. Donโ€™t worry about what that difference is for now (learn it if you want to take up chess), but know that strong players will only strategize while it is their opponentโ€™s turn, and only calculate (tactics) while it is their own turn. Itโ€™s very tempting to flit constantly between one and the other, but chess requires players to have the mental discipline be able to focus on one task or the other and stick with that task until itโ€™s the appointed time to switch.

    If you feel like taking up chess, this site (and related app, if you want it) is free (it’s been funded by voluntary donations for a long time now) and good and even comes with free tuition and training tools: LiChess.org

    Here’s another site that this writer (hi, it’s me) personally usesโ€”it has great features too, but many are paywalled (I’m mostly there just because I’ve been there nearly since its inception, so I’m baked into the community now): Chess.com

    Want to know more?

    You might like this book by Dr. Chapman, which we havenโ€™t reviewed yet but it did inform large parts of todayโ€™s article:

    Make Your Brain Smarter: Increase Your Brain’s Creativity, Energy, and Focus โ€“ by Dr. Sandra Chapman

    Enjoy!

    Don’t Forget…

    Did you arrive here from our newsletter? Don’t forget to return to the email to continue learning!

    Learn to Age Gracefully

    Join the 98k+ American women taking control of their health & aging with our 100% free (and fun!) daily emails:

  • Montana Eyes $30M Revamp of Mental Health, Developmental Disability Facilities

    10almonds is reader-supported. We may, at no cost to you, receive a portion of sales if you purchase a product through a link in this article.

    HELENA, Mont. โ€” As part of a proposed revamping of the stateโ€™s behavioral health system, Republican Gov. Greg Gianforteโ€™s administration is looking into moving a facility for people with developmental disabilities, beefing up renovations at the Montana State Hospital, and creating a Helena unit of that psychiatric hospital.

    The changes, backers say, would fill gaps in services and help people better prepare for life outside of the locked, secure setting of the two state facilities before they reenter their own communities.

    โ€œI think part of the theme is responsibly moving people in and out of the state facilities so that we create capacity and have people in the appropriate places,โ€ state Sen. Dave Fern (D-Whitefish) said of the proposed capital projects during a recent interview.

    Fern served on the Behavioral Health System for Future Generations Commission, a panel created by a 2023 law to suggest how to spend $300 million to revamp the system. The law set aside the $300 million for improving state services for people with mental illness, substance abuse disorders, and developmental disabilities.

    Gianforteโ€™s proposed budget for the next two years would spend about $100 million of that fund on 10 other recommendations from the commission. The capital projects are separate ideas for using up to $32.5 million of the $75 million earmarked within the $300 million pool of funds for building new infrastructure or remodeling existing buildings.

    The state Department of Public Health and Human Services and consultants for the behavioral health commission presented commission members with areas for capital investments in October. In December, the commission authorized state health department director Charlie Brereton to recommend the following projects to Gianforte:

    • Move the 12-bed Intensive Behavior Center for people with developmental disabilities out of Boulder, possibly to either Helena or Butte, at an estimated cost of up to $13.3 million.
    • Establish a โ€œstep-downโ€ facility of about 16 beds, possibly on the campus of Shodair Childrenโ€™s Hospital in Helena, to serve adults who have been committed to the Montana State Hospital but no longer need the hospitalโ€™s intensive psychiatric services.
    • Invest $19.2 million to upgrade the Montana State Hospitalโ€™s infrastructure and buildings at Warm Springs, on top of nearly $16 million appropriated in 2023 for renovations already underway there in an effort to regain federal certification of the facility.

    The state Architecture & Engineering Division is reviewing the health departmentโ€™s cost estimates and developing a timeline for the projects so the information can be sent to the governor. Gianforte ultimately must approve the projects.

    Health department officials have said they plan to take the proposals to legislative committees as needed. โ€œWith Commission recommendation and approval from the governor, the Department believes that it has the authority to proceed with capital project expenditures but must secure additional authority from the Legislature to fund operations into future biennia,โ€ said department spokesperson Jon Ebelt.

    The department outlined its facility plans to the legislatureโ€™s health and human services budget subcommittee on Jan. 22 as part of a larger presentation on the commissionโ€™s work and the 10 noncapital proposals in the governorโ€™s budget. Time limits prevented in-depth discussion and public comment on the facility-related ideas.

    One change the commission didnโ€™t consider: moving the Montana State Hospital to a more populated area from its rural and relatively remote location near Anaconda, in southwestern Montana, in an attempt to alleviate staffing shortages.

    โ€œThe administration is committed to continuing to invest in MSH as it exists today,โ€ Brereton told the commission in October, referring to the Montana State Hospital.

    The hospital provides treatment to people with mental illness who have been committed to the stateโ€™s custody through a civil or criminal proceeding. Itโ€™s been beset by problems, including the loss of federal Medicaid and Medicare funding due to decertification by the federal government in April 2022, staffing issues that have led to high use of expensive traveling health care providers, and turnover in leadership.

    State Sen. Chris Pope (D-Bozeman) was vice chair of a separate committee that met between the 2023 and 2025 legislative sessions and monitored progress toward a 2023 legislative mandate to transition patients with dementia out of the state hospital. He agreed in a recent interview that improving โ€” not moving โ€” MSH is a top priority for the system right now.

    โ€œRight now, we have an institution that is failing and needs to be brought back into the modern age, where it is located right now,โ€ he said after ticking off a list of challenges facing the hospital.

    State Sen. John Esp (R-Big Timber) also noted at the October commission meeting that moving the hospital was likely to run into resistance in any community considered for a new facility.

    Fern, the Whitefish senator, questioned in October whether similar concerns might exist for moving the Intensive Behavior Center out of Boulder. For more than 130 years, the town 30 miles south of Helena has been home, in one form or another, to a state facility for people with developmental disabilities. But Brereton said he believes relocation could succeed with community and stakeholder involvement.

    The 12-bed center in Boulder serves people who have been committed by a court because their behaviors pose an immediate risk of serious harm to themselves or others. Itโ€™s the last residential building for people with developmental disabilities on the campus of the former Montana Developmental Center, which the legislature voted in 2015 to close.

    Drew Smith, a consultant with the firm Alvarez & Marsal, told the commission in October that moving the facility from the town of 1,300 to a bigger city such as Helena or Butte would provide access to a larger labor pool, possibly allow a more homelike setting for residents, and open more opportunities for residents to interact with the community and develop skills for returning to their own communities.

    Ideally, Brereton said, the center would be colocated with a new facility included in the governorโ€™s proposed budget, for crisis stabilization services to people with developmental disabilities who are experiencing significant behavioral health issues.

    Meanwhile, the proposed subacute facility with up to 16 beds for state hospital patients would provide a still secure but less structured setting for people who no longer need intensive treatment at Warm Springs but arenโ€™t yet ready to be discharged from the hospitalโ€™s care. Brereton told the commission in October the facility would essentially serve as a less restrictive โ€œextensionโ€ of the state hospital. He also said the agency would like to contract with a company to staff the subacute facility.

    Health department officials donโ€™t expect the new facility to involve any construction costs. Brereton has said the agency believes an existing building on the Shodair campus would be a good spot for it.

    The state began leasing the building Nov. 1 for use by about 20 state hospital patients displaced by the current remodeling at Warm Springs โ€” a different purpose than the proposed subacute facility.

    Shodair CEO Craig Aasved said Shodair hasnโ€™t committed to having the state permanently use the building as the step-down facility envisioned by the agency and the commission.

    But Brereton said the option is attractive to the health department now that the building has been set up and licensed to serve adults.

    โ€œIt seems like a natural place to start,โ€ he told the commission in December, โ€œand we donโ€™t mind that itโ€™s in our backyard here in Helena.โ€

    Republish This Story

    KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFFโ€”an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about KFF.

    Subscribe to KFF Health News’ free Morning Briefing.

    This article first appeared on KFF Health News and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

    Don’t Forget…

    Did you arrive here from our newsletter? Don’t forget to return to the email to continue learning!

    Learn to Age Gracefully

    Join the 98k+ American women taking control of their health & aging with our 100% free (and fun!) daily emails: