How Much Do Activity Trackers Actually Get People To Move More?

10almonds is reader-supported. We may, at no cost to you, receive a portion of sales if you purchase a product through a link in this article.

Is it really a motivating factor, or does the novelty quickly wear off and it becomes a watch with some notifications to ignore?

What gets measured, gets done

Researchers (Dr. Ju-Pil Choe et al.) analyzed data from 5,804 adults, to identify patterns of digital health technology use and their relationship with physical activity.

Now, obviously there’s a degree of reporting bias here, insofar as we have a lot more data from those using tracking devices, but it did use data from the 2024 Health Information National Trends Survey responses, so it didn’t just take a “I do not see it” approach to exercise that was not tracked with activity trackers.

That said, we’ll mention up front that this was an observational study, and association cannot outright prove causality.

You can learn more about that, here: How Science News Outlets Can Lie To You (Yes, Even If They Cite Studies!)

Still, the numbers do seem telling, as you’ll see…

Of the respondents to that survey, the researchers identified four groups, namely:

  • broad multidomain users (32%)
  • wearable-centered users (11.8%)
  • patient portal-centered users (34.3%)
  • people with limited digital engagement (21.9%)

Regardless of group, people are people, and so for everyone the recommended targets were the standard, that regular 10almonds readers will know already: at least 150 minutes of moderate aerobic activity per week and muscle-strengthening activities at least twice weekly.

Of these, about 1 in 3 people with broad digital engagement or wearable-centered engagement met both guidelines, compared with about 1 in 5 people who primarily used patient portals or had limited digital engagement.

In other words, those with activity trackers, or at least tech involvement, did better.

In particular, all three digitally engaged groups had higher odds of meeting the muscle-strengthening guideline than the limited-engagement group, while only broad multidomain engagement was significantly associated with meeting the aerobic guideline.

But let’s put it into numbers: after accounting for age, income, and education, broad multidomain users had 2.79x the odds of meeting both guidelines, while wearable-centered users had 2.13x the odds, compared with people with limited digital engagement.

In other words: the more tech, the better.

That said, older adults and people with lower incomes were more represented among those with limited digital engagement, raising concerns that exercise programs relying heavily on apps and wearable devices could exclude people who might benefit (sometimes: the most!) from additional support.

You can read the paper itself, here: Digital health engagement profiles and physical activity guideline adherence among adults in the United States: a latent class analysis

Want to learn more?

Activity trackers definitely have their weaknesses as well as their strengths:

What Your Fitness Tracker Is Best & Worst At

And if you’d like a deeper dive into how to truly motivate yourself to exercise more, then you might like this book that we reviewed a while back:

I Will Make You Passionate About Exercise: How to go from being unmotivated, unfit and lost, to having energy, being fit, healthy and loving exercise – by Bevan Eyles

Take care!

Don’t Forget…

Did you arrive here from our newsletter? Don’t forget to return to the email to continue learning!

Learn to Age Gracefully

Join the 98k+ American women taking control of their health & aging with our 100% free (and fun!) daily emails: